CoverageNorth YorkshireNew dwellings in gardens

New house in a garden planning permission refused in North Yorkshire

Most were refused over design. We read 46 of the 48 new dwellings in gardens North Yorkshire refused in the last three years and sorted each by what its reasons were about. Each dot is one of them.

Get the forecast for your address
  1. Design and character of the area 26 of 46

  2. Green Belt and open countryside 20 of 46

  3. Insufficient information 10 of 46

  4. Neighbours' amenity 10 of 46

  5. Principle of development 10 of 46

  6. Trees, landscape and ecology 9 of 46

  7. Heritage assets 8 of 46

  8. Flooding and drainage 7 of 46

Each dot is one refusal. A refusal usually gives more than one reason, so it can stand in more than one row.

Also cited: highways and parking (7), living conditions for future occupiers (5).

Of the 46 refusals of new dwellings in gardens North Yorkshire made in the last three years that we read, 57% were refused at least in part over design or the character of the area. Plan Forecast, 22 November 2026.

01

Design and character of the area

of the refusals we read

26 of the 46 new dwellings in gardens North Yorkshire refused that we read gave a reason about how the work looked, or how it sat in its street: its size, its shape, its materials.

How the councils compare

  • Bromley 77%
  • Croydon 75%
  • East Devon 59%
  • Buckinghamshire 57%
  • East Suffolk 57%
  • North Yorkshire 57%
  • Leeds 55%
  • Epping Forest 54%
  • East Riding of Yorkshire 47%
  • Shropshire 46%
  • East Hertfordshire 41%

Share of each council's refused new dwellings in gardens we read that gave a reason about it.

02

Green Belt and open countryside

of the refusals we read

20 of the 46 new dwellings in gardens North Yorkshire refused that we read gave a reason about building in the Green Belt or open countryside.

How the councils compare

  • Epping Forest 54%
  • Shropshire 44%
  • North Yorkshire 43%
  • Buckinghamshire 35%
  • East Hertfordshire 34%
  • East Devon 30%
  • East Riding of Yorkshire 26%
  • Bromley 23%
  • East Suffolk 23%
  • Leeds 10%
  • Croydon 5%

Share of each council's refused new dwellings in gardens we read that gave a reason about it.

03

Insufficient information

of the refusals we read

10 of the 46 new dwellings in gardens North Yorkshire refused that we read gave a reason about drawings or details the council needed and did not have.

?

How the councils compare

  • East Hertfordshire 56%
  • Croydon 55%
  • Epping Forest 48%
  • Shropshire 33%
  • Buckinghamshire 25%
  • East Suffolk 23%
  • North Yorkshire 22%
  • Bromley 21%
  • East Riding of Yorkshire 18%
  • Leeds 10%
  • East Devon 8%

Share of each council's refused new dwellings in gardens we read that gave a reason about it.

04

Neighbours' amenity

of the refusals we read

10 of the 46 new dwellings in gardens North Yorkshire refused that we read gave a reason about the people next door: their light, their outlook, their privacy, the sense of being hemmed in.

45°

How the councils compare

  • Croydon 48%
  • Bromley 42%
  • East Riding of Yorkshire 39%
  • Leeds 26%
  • North Yorkshire 22%
  • Buckinghamshire 20%
  • East Devon 14%
  • Epping Forest 13%
  • East Suffolk 10%
  • Shropshire 10%
  • East Hertfordshire 9%

Share of each council's refused new dwellings in gardens we read that gave a reason about it.

05

Principle of development

of the refusals we read

10 of the 46 new dwellings in gardens North Yorkshire refused that we read gave a reason about whether that kind of building belongs there at all.

How the councils compare

  • East Devon 22%
  • North Yorkshire 22%
  • Shropshire 19%
  • East Riding of Yorkshire 11%
  • East Hertfordshire 9%
  • Epping Forest 7%
  • Croydon 5%
  • Buckinghamshire 4%
  • East Suffolk 3%
  • Leeds 3%
  • Bromley 0%

Share of each council's refused new dwellings in gardens we read that gave a reason about it.

Also cited

  • Trees, landscape and ecology 9 of 46
  • Heritage assets 8 of 46
  • Flooding and drainage 7 of 46
  • Highways and parking 7 of 46
  • Living conditions for future occupiers 5 of 46

Policies cited most

The plans and policies North Yorkshire's refusals named, each counted once a refusal.

  • National Planning Policy Framework 38 of 46
  • ENV1, Local Plan 14 of 46
  • HP3, Local Plan 13 of 46
  • GS2, Local Plan 10 of 46
  • GS3, Local Plan 10 of 46
  • NE4, Local Plan 10 of 46

How we count

These are North Yorkshire's own refusals of new dwellings in gardens, decided in the last three years and listed on its register. For each one we read the decision notice and sorted its reasons by what they were about. 2 we have not read yet; they are counted as refusals and not as refusals without reasons.

A refusal usually gives more than one reason, so the shares add up to more than a hundred. Which refusals they were, where, and what each said, is in the Planning Forecast for your address, with a link to each council's own notice.

What North Yorkshire approves · Why new dwellings in gardens are refused at every council we read · Why planning permission gets refused, anywhere

Free check

Check your project

Put a pin on your house, describe the work, and see it measured against each permitted development limit, with the clause it comes from. A guide, not a guarantee.

Check it free →

Get the forecast for your address

The rate for what you are planning, how long a decision takes, and what happened on your own streets. Free, and we email it to you.

Free, in about a minute. We email it to you.