CoverageYork

York planning permission refused: the reasons, counted

Most were refused over design. We read 210 of the 211 applications for building work York refused in the last three years and sorted each by what its reasons were about. Each dot is one of them.

Get the forecast for your address
  1. Design and character of the area 147 of 210

  2. Neighbours' amenity 59 of 210

  3. Highways and parking 28 of 210

  4. Green Belt and open countryside 26 of 210

  5. Heritage assets 14 of 210

  6. Living conditions for future occupiers 9 of 210

  7. Trees, landscape and ecology 5 of 210

  8. Flooding and drainage 4 of 210

Each dot is one refusal. A refusal usually gives more than one reason, so it can stand in more than one row.

Also cited: insufficient information (4), not permitted development (2), principle of development (2).

Of the 210 refusals of building work York made in the last three years that we read, 70% were refused at least in part over design or the character of the area. Plan Forecast, 22 November 2026.

01

Design and character of the area

of the refusals we read

147 of the 210 applications for building work York refused that we read gave a reason about how the work looked, or how it sat in its street: its size, its shape, its materials.

How the councils compare

  • Bolton 80%
  • Luton 80%
  • Gravesham 77%
  • Trafford 74%
  • Manchester 73%
  • Newham 73%
  • West Oxfordshire 73%
  • Cheshire West and Chester 72%
  • Folkestone and Hythe 72%
  • Swindon 72%
  • Haringey 71%
  • Leeds 71%
  • Bromley 70%
  • Calderdale 70%
  • York 70%
  • North Hertfordshire 68%
  • Cheltenham 67%
  • South Gloucestershire 67%
  • Epping Forest 66%
  • Lambeth 63%
  • Rochdale 63%
  • Reading 61%
  • Wakefield 60%
  • East Hertfordshire 58%
  • East Suffolk 58%
  • Nottingham 58%
  • Salford 58%
  • East Riding of Yorkshire 57%
  • Tower Hamlets 57%
  • Croydon 56%
  • Lancaster 56%
  • West Suffolk 56%
  • East Devon 55%
  • Sutton 54%
  • Shropshire 53%
  • Kingston upon Thames 52%
  • Milton Keynes 52%
  • Test Valley 52%
  • Dacorum 51%
  • Huntingdonshire 51%
  • North Yorkshire 51%
  • Buckinghamshire 50%
  • Dover 50%
  • Ealing 50%
  • Southend-on-Sea 50%
  • Tendring 50%
  • Mid Sussex 49%
  • Newark and Sherwood 49%
  • Ashford 48%
  • North Norfolk 48%
  • Northumberland 48%
  • Teignbridge 48%
  • Wolverhampton 48%
  • Guildford 47%
  • Westminster 47%
  • North Somerset 46%
  • Tameside 46%
  • Brent 45%
  • Enfield 45%
  • Solihull 45%
  • Tonbridge and Malling 44%
  • County Durham 43%
  • Southwark 43%
  • Stockport 41%
  • Cotswold 40%
  • Dartford 39%
  • Three Rivers 39%
  • Hertsmere 38%
  • Bracknell Forest 37%
  • Sevenoaks 33%

Share of each council's refused applications for building work we read that gave a reason about it.

02

Neighbours' amenity

of the refusals we read

59 of the 210 applications for building work York refused that we read gave a reason about the people next door: their light, their outlook, their privacy, the sense of being hemmed in.

45°

How the councils compare

  • Wolverhampton 63%
  • Reading 61%
  • Hertsmere 52%
  • Manchester 50%
  • Dartford 48%
  • Nottingham 46%
  • Croydon 42%
  • Haringey 42%
  • Enfield 41%
  • Salford 41%
  • Southwark 41%
  • Luton 40%
  • Rochdale 39%
  • Sutton 39%
  • Lancaster 37%
  • Bromley 34%
  • East Riding of Yorkshire 34%
  • North Hertfordshire 34%
  • Tameside 34%
  • Leeds 33%
  • Tower Hamlets 33%
  • Kingston upon Thames 32%
  • Newham 32%
  • Stockport 32%
  • Tendring 32%
  • Trafford 32%
  • Bolton 31%
  • Cheltenham 31%
  • Milton Keynes 31%
  • Wakefield 31%
  • Brent 30%
  • Southend-on-Sea 30%
  • Calderdale 29%
  • County Durham 29%
  • York 28%
  • Cheshire West and Chester 27%
  • Gravesham 27%
  • Guildford 27%
  • Lambeth 26%
  • North Yorkshire 26%
  • Epping Forest 25%
  • Three Rivers 25%
  • Ealing 24%
  • East Suffolk 24%
  • Swindon 24%
  • Solihull 23%
  • Folkestone and Hythe 22%
  • North Somerset 22%
  • Northumberland 22%
  • Huntingdonshire 21%
  • South Gloucestershire 21%
  • Teignbridge 21%
  • North Norfolk 20%
  • Buckinghamshire 19%
  • Dacorum 19%
  • Dover 16%
  • East Devon 15%
  • East Hertfordshire 15%
  • Cotswold 14%
  • Sevenoaks 14%
  • Test Valley 14%
  • Westminster 14%
  • Mid Sussex 13%
  • West Suffolk 13%
  • Shropshire 12%
  • Tonbridge and Malling 9%
  • West Oxfordshire 9%
  • Newark and Sherwood 8%
  • Ashford 7%
  • Bracknell Forest 4%

Share of each council's refused applications for building work we read that gave a reason about it.

03

Highways and parking

of the refusals we read

28 of the 210 applications for building work York refused that we read gave a reason about parking, access, or the safety of the road outside.

How the councils compare

  • Bracknell Forest 35%
  • Wolverhampton 27%
  • Croydon 25%
  • County Durham 18%
  • Brent 16%
  • North Norfolk 16%
  • Huntingdonshire 15%
  • South Gloucestershire 15%
  • Swindon 15%
  • Lambeth 14%
  • Dacorum 13%
  • Northumberland 13%
  • Three Rivers 13%
  • York 13%
  • East Riding of Yorkshire 12%
  • Milton Keynes 12%
  • Nottingham 12%
  • Cheltenham 11%
  • East Suffolk 11%
  • West Suffolk 11%
  • Ashford 10%
  • Calderdale 10%
  • Kingston upon Thames 10%
  • Luton 10%
  • Newark and Sherwood 10%
  • Test Valley 10%
  • Dover 9%
  • Wakefield 9%
  • Leeds 8%
  • North Yorkshire 8%
  • Shropshire 8%
  • Sutton 8%
  • Folkestone and Hythe 7%
  • Gravesham 7%
  • Manchester 7%
  • North Hertfordshire 7%
  • North Somerset 7%
  • Stockport 7%
  • Buckinghamshire 6%
  • Cotswold 6%
  • East Devon 6%
  • Reading 6%
  • Sevenoaks 6%
  • Ealing 5%
  • East Hertfordshire 5%
  • Enfield 5%
  • Hertsmere 5%
  • Newham 5%
  • Southwark 5%
  • Tonbridge and Malling 5%
  • Tower Hamlets 5%
  • Bolton 4%
  • Epping Forest 4%
  • Guildford 4%
  • Haringey 4%
  • Lancaster 4%
  • Rochdale 4%
  • Tendring 4%
  • Bromley 3%
  • Dartford 3%
  • Mid Sussex 3%
  • Salford 3%
  • Solihull 3%
  • Southend-on-Sea 3%
  • Teignbridge 3%
  • Cheshire West and Chester 2%
  • Tameside 2%
  • Trafford 1%
  • West Oxfordshire 1%
  • Westminster 1%

Share of each council's refused applications for building work we read that gave a reason about it.

04

Green Belt and open countryside

of the refusals we read

26 of the 210 applications for building work York refused that we read gave a reason about building in the Green Belt or open countryside.

How the councils compare

  • Sevenoaks 46%
  • Tonbridge and Malling 44%
  • Guildford 37%
  • Cheshire West and Chester 29%
  • Bracknell Forest 28%
  • Dacorum 28%
  • East Hertfordshire 27%
  • Epping Forest 25%
  • Calderdale 24%
  • North Somerset 24%
  • West Suffolk 24%
  • County Durham 22%
  • North Yorkshire 20%
  • Shropshire 20%
  • East Devon 19%
  • Huntingdonshire 19%
  • South Gloucestershire 19%
  • Three Rivers 19%
  • Wakefield 18%
  • Northumberland 17%
  • Dover 16%
  • Newark and Sherwood 16%
  • Test Valley 16%
  • Buckinghamshire 15%
  • North Hertfordshire 15%
  • Solihull 14%
  • Gravesham 12%
  • York 12%
  • East Suffolk 11%
  • Ashford 10%
  • East Riding of Yorkshire 10%
  • Bromley 9%
  • Cotswold 9%
  • Teignbridge 8%
  • Mid Sussex 7%
  • North Norfolk 7%
  • Tendring 7%
  • Cheltenham 6%
  • Dartford 6%
  • Leeds 6%
  • Rochdale 6%
  • Bolton 5%
  • Folkestone and Hythe 5%
  • Hertsmere 5%
  • Tameside 5%
  • Lancaster 4%
  • Milton Keynes 4%
  • Stockport 4%
  • Salford 3%
  • West Oxfordshire 3%
  • Croydon 1%
  • Kingston upon Thames 1%
  • Southend-on-Sea 1%
  • Sutton 1%
  • Brent 0%
  • Ealing 0%
  • Enfield 0%
  • Haringey 0%
  • Lambeth 0%
  • Luton 0%
  • Manchester 0%
  • Newham 0%
  • Nottingham 0%
  • Reading 0%
  • Southwark 0%
  • Swindon 0%
  • Tower Hamlets 0%
  • Trafford 0%
  • Westminster 0%
  • Wolverhampton 0%

Share of each council's refused applications for building work we read that gave a reason about it.

Also cited

  • Heritage assets 14 of 210
  • Living conditions for future occupiers 9 of 210
  • Trees, landscape and ecology 5 of 210
  • Flooding and drainage 4 of 210
  • Insufficient information 4 of 210
  • Not permitted development 2 of 210
  • Principle of development 2 of 210

How we count

These are York's own refusals of every kind of work we sort applications into (work we cannot name is left out), decided in the last three years and listed on its register. For each one we read the decision notice and sorted its reasons by what they were about. 1 we have not read yet; they are counted as refusals and not as refusals without reasons.

A refusal usually gives more than one reason, so the shares add up to more than a hundred. Which refusals they were, where, and what each said, is in the Planning Forecast for your address, with a link to each council's own notice.

What York approves · Why planning permission gets refused, anywhere

Free check

Check your project

Put a pin on your house, describe the work, and see it measured against each permitted development limit, with the clause it comes from. A guide, not a guarantee.

Check it free →

Get the forecast for your address

The rate for what you are planning, how long a decision takes, and what happened on your own streets. Free, and we email it to you.

Free, in about a minute. We email it to you.